Wow..this was the 2nd time I attempted to order from this place. First time the pizza showed up an hour and a half after I ordered it. The delivery guy had to call me 3 times to find my house and when he finally got to my house the top of the pizza box was smashed into the pizza destroying it. It then took over an hour to get a new one and the same delivery boy was expecting a tip even. Mind blowing. The 2nd time I ordered just chicken fingers and hot wings, figuring if I kept it simple they couldn't mess it up. They showed up with chicken fingers and some wings drenched in cold Italian dressing. They sent me my wings an hour later and once again messed it up. They were just chicken wings with no hot sauce. How do you mess up a single order twice?? Never ordering from them again.

I'm from the city and OIP is the closest pie in watertown hands down! Great pizza a little expensive but I'd have one great pie than 3 garbage ones from little ceasars

I finally went to OIP this week and absolutely loved it! I have never tasted wings as good as their char-grilled variety. The cheese pizza was gooey (NOT greasy), I loved that the sauce used was not overly sweet - as this can be an issue in Northern NY. Their variety of huge slices available during the lunch hour was impressive. And even though they got slammed with customers the day I went in, staff working there were very friendly!

I have loved OIP since they opened, they are great people with great food at good prices.

Do not waste your money at other pizza joints. This is, by far, the best pizza in town! Priced right and delivered fast! I've never had a better pizza experience.

Highly reccomended!!!! Love the pizza and the wings!! In my opinion, best in town now!!!!