Excellent pizza the best in the area for quite some time. I go out of my way for it and the excellent service

been bring my girlfriends n friends there since the 80's Donna n brother use to work there along w/dad. Simply the best pizza! Even though I do not live close. I have fond memories of the delicious pizza I measure all other pizza's to!

you'll love it ! yummy. Mmmm

Great Pizza. The first time my family went to Colosseo was after we moved to the Setauket area nine years ago. We sat down and the waitress came to take our order. I told her we didn't get our menus yet. She looked at me like I was crazy. At Colosseo you can get anything you want as long as it's Pizza! There are a few exceptions, you can get a simple iceberg lettuce salad with thin sliced grape tomatoes and chopped celery. The salad has a light oil and vinegar dressing and goes well with Pizza. On a friday night there will be no fewer than 20 to 25 people working behind the counter. I'm not exaggerating. The wait for a table isn't too bad...even with a long line it takes only 10 to 15 minutes. The dining area in the back is a little tight and expect your pie to end up on a tray table in the aisle if you have 4 or more at your table. If all you want is great Pizza then Colosseo is the place to go.

The Best Pizza on LI. Friday Nights are packed and the Pizza arent as good that night

I HAVE BEEN VISITING THIS ESTABLISHMENT FOR OVER 20 YEARS. NO MATTER WHERE ELSE I GO, NOONE COMPARES.THE PIZZA IS FANTASTIC.THE SERVICE IS A1.